Plaintiff raised objections to Lampert's interrogatories but stated that the alter ego contentions are supported by documents produced by plaintiff on April 23, 2010 and documents . PDF Piercing the Corporate Veil: Minimizing Alter Ego When deciding whether a company is a mere alter ego, courts examine such factors as: failure to The sample document on which this preview is based is very detailed and is 33 pages long including the declaration for additional discovery and proof . Answer to complaint: Alter Ego Things - Rain Barrel Sculpture The issue of establishing alter ego status for jurisdictional purposes is not presented here, as neither party has challenged the court's jurisdiction on that basis. Joanne Siegel et al v. Warner Bros Entertainment Inc et al PDF Piercing the damages - Advocate Magazine Sample written interrogatories under Federal Rule of Civil (Consolidated Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, McGranahan v. Bell , Adv. Ct. 1998) (discussing the "alter ego theory of piercing the corporate veil"). It can occur when an employer or other person subject to the Act intentionally excludes individuals from an employment opportunity on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. When to File a Protective Order in Business Litigation The law of alter ego allows a party to pierce the corporate veil and pursue the shareholders of the corporation based on the manner in which they have dealt with the corporation. 3 is in the affirmative, state all FACTS which support YOUR contention. Pro. 19 pages) defendants, Pocahontas, East Gulf Coal and East Gulf Coast are the alter ego of defendant United." . PDF Piercing the Corporate Veil: Minimizing Alter Ego Plaintiffs sued a series of individuals and corporate entities for construction defects, fraud and conspiracy. Keatinge, Section 12.3 Alter ego, or the concept that the member/shareholder is one and the same as the LLC/corporation, is a frequent basis for disregarding the shield of limited liability. ed. Plaintiffs alleged that the defendants "converted property . under "alter ego" and "piercing the corporate veil" theory. About the Author. Yet, the type of "alter-ego" relatedness that was central to that previous holding is only one means of demonstrating a corporate relationship sufficient for Rule 34 purposes. AppA Special Interrogatories AppB Special Interrogatories - For Cases brought by Non-Prisoners (Prison Litigation Reform does not apply) Defendants assert Plaintiff has not explained how discovery of Akinyemi's other business entities would establish alter ego. '1983 Claims C Fourth Amendment Claim C Private Person Alleging Motion to Bifurcate Alter Ego Claims and to Stay Discovery, filed by the Superior Court of California on October 3, 2007, is attached hereto as Exhibit V. First City sought various organizational documents from both parties relevant to the possible existence of an alter ego relationship. Corp., 722 A.2d 691, 694 (Pa. Super. FORM NO. The trial court ruled in favor of General . 4 Tips for Contention Interrogatories - CEBblog No. Over 300 sample legal documents for California and Federal litigation available from LegalDocsPro. The district court determined that LFC Marketing was the alter ego of William, and thus ordered that the Loomises' judgment be satisfied out of the attached commissions. ( Associated Vendors, Inc. v. Oakland Meat Co. (1962) 210 Cal.App.2d 825) Factors that lend to alter ego liability include the commingling of corporate funds, failure . Understanding Alter Ego Liability - 11/28/21. Prior to answering the remainder of these interrogatories, state whether you have made inquiry of the officers, servants, and employees of the defendant employer, and have referred to documents, correspondence, memoranda, records, and other papers in the possession of the defendant employer, as will enable you to make the corporate veil" and proving that the company "The Right Move" is an "alter ego" of the Respondent. 49: The Alter Ego of a Corporation ('Piercing the Corporate Veil') FORM NO. SPECIAL INTERROGATORY NO. If YOUR response to Interrogatory No. (Ballantine, Corporations (rev. The Court will conduc t a final pre-trial conference in connection with the alter ego claim on January 12, 2009, at 11:00 a.m . Interrogatories to defendantsAlter ego CACF-CORP 800 Form 6 Jay E. Grenig West's California Code Forms with Commentaries, Corporations (Approx. 17 . Erin McGlogan manages development initiatives for the firm's practice areas encompassing financial institutions, finance, and securities. CCP 2030.060 . On the alter ego issue, Cresson testified that he was president of CDC, but never served in any other office, "never [was] the responsible managing officer," and "never held a majority position."4 He presented a printout from the Contractors State License Board showing that CDC was a licensed general contractor, Robert Kulda was the . The alter ego claim shall be tried to this Court on January 20, 2009, at 9:30 a.m., in Courtroom One. Strategies Regarding Corporate Veil Piercing and Alter Ego Doctrine July 31, 2018 15 Successful Veil-Piercing Allegations 41102(a) and 46 . The U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada quashed a third party subpoena on a bank because the subpoena was overbroad. Accordingly, the interrogatories set forth in this section explore the defendant's contentions regarding the claim that liability should be precluded because the defendant is the alter ego of the other party to the contract. Do YOU contend that MVE+P, Inc. is an alter ego of MVP? 800 Form 6. Consistent with this Court's February 24, 2010 Order (see Docket No. 292-293; Lattin, Corporations, p. 66; Latty, The Corporate Entity as a Solvent of Legal Problems, 34 Mich.L . reports or accidents may be due to a nonex 1 stent or poor accident reporting system. The initial window for answering a request for interrogatories is 30 days, so a protective order must be sought early on in the legal proceedings. The "alter ego" doctrine allows a party to pierce the corporate veil and pursue shareholders of a corporation based upon the manner in which the corporation has been managed. B. McNamara Is Alter Ego of Sierra Capital In order to recover the full $260,135.00 against McNamara, the Receiver asks the Court to pierce Sierra's corporate veil, arguing that Sierra is an alter ego of McNamara. Correlation Tables. The interrogatories showed that both the actual intent and substantial certainty standards were before the jury. General Fidelity sought to pierce the corporate veil so that Blessmatch, Alpha, and Fleming could be held liable for WFT's debts. It is, however, "the plaintiff's burden to overcome the presumption of separate existence of the corporate entity." To establish an alter ego theory of liability . If YOUR response to Interrogatory No. Request for Admissions is a common request in the Discovery process of a lawsuit. CBI responded and later supplemented its response. Glen Bell has a long history of using nominee and alter ego devices to avoid creditors and debt liability. See Benson v . These answers are legally binding, and the opposing party must answer them truthfully or run the risk of committing perjury. Interrogatories . BT Visual Images, L.L.C. A corporation is a separate legal entity. alter-ego liability. Plaintiff alleges that Rieck is the alter ego of the Calvest Malibu and that Calvest Malibu is the alter ego of Rieck. SPECIAL INTERROGATORY NO. Seven sample legal document collections also available for both California and Federal litigation. Las Vegas Office: 6671 S. Las Vegas Blvd., Suite 210, Las Vegas, NV 89119, Ph: 702-953-9617, Fax: 877-698-0678. Adam is a serial entrepreneur from Melbourne that also spent more than a decade living in Los Angeles. II. Special interrogatories 46 - 75 relate to alter ego allegations, and as already noted, 76 - 90 relate to damages. In re Porsche, 2012 WL 4361430, at *4. serve interrogatories and requests for production, and to conduct Rule 30(b)(6) depositions. PLAINTIFF'S SPECIAL INTERROGATORIES, SET ONE S ELARZ L AW C ORP. Aug. 02, 2013. Instead, liability attaches where the record establishes the individual's participation in the tortious activity. 9,596 views. The use of contention interrogatories - that is, interrogatories seeking the facts, witnesses and documents supporting a single contention - has been a feature of California litigation for at least four de-cades. Determining the Alter Ego. [19771 19 Cal .3d 22) and/or alter ego liability (Associated Oklahoma [1962] 210 cal.App.2d . In response, Defendants argue the interrogatories are unrelated to the issues in this case since there is no reasonable connection between the information sought and the alleged wrongful eviction of Plaintiff. These sample written interrogatories under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 33 are designed for use by a plaintiff in a federal district court case but can be modified for use by a defendant. Of course, there are tougher cases and some examples follow: There no was Don't despair. The Complainant maintains that the interrogatories and the requested documents 1 through 11 go to heart and core of this complaint in establishing violations of 46 U.S.C. AlphaCap later filed a sur-reply on September 21. The alter ego doctrine supplies the rationale for a court's decision to pierce the corporate veil. In Jett, the Court had specifically stated that it was inappropriate to consider a foreman a corporation ' s alter ego. The time within which petitioner may file such amendment has been extended and has not yet expired.petitioner then served on Thriftimart the interrogatories herein involved, which seek to obtain from Thriftimart information that might enable petitioner to plead its alter ego theory with more particularity. 1219.) Request for Admissions. Sample documents for United States District Court. Travis J. Ketterman is a partner with the Chicago law firm of Whitfield McGann & Ketterman, where his practice is devoted to representing labor organizations and multiemployer fringe benefit trust funds in federal court litigation. The Creditors argue that a trustee can only sue to recover About the Author. The "alter ego" doctrine allows a party to pierce the corporate veil and pursue shareholders of a corporation based upon the manner in which the corporation has been managed. In October 1994, First City served its first set of interrogatories and document requests on CBI and Rafidain. As the parties were undergoing venue discovery, counsel for CCP 2030.060 . 2d 542 . The defendant shall serve verified responses without objection within 20 days. More about Adam Radly here.. After nearly two months of venue discovery, AlphaCap filed an opposition to Gust's motion on September 1. '1983 Claims C First Amendment Claim C Prisoner Alleging Retaliation or Denial of Access to Courts 337 5.2 Civil Rights C 42 U.S.C. The actual sample is 9 pages long and includes 14 . The following is an example of alter-ego allegations: Plaintiff is informed and believes, and based thereon alleges, that Defendant [Corporate Entity] is the alter ego of Defendants [individual owners], and DOES 1 through 25, inclusive, in that it has maintained such a unity of interest and ownership Travis J. Ketterman is a partner with the Chicago law firm of Whitfield McGann & Ketterman, where his practice is devoted to representing labor organizations and multiemployer fringe benefit trust funds in federal court litigation. Body. Furthermore, Plaintiff alleges that all of the corporate defendants are alter egos of Rieck. 1994); Bullion v. Gillespie, Interrogatories and Request for Production on August 22, 2008. interrogatories, and admissions on file, designate specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial. We first conclude that the procedure employed by the Loomises using a writ of attachment to aid in post-judgment recovery is allowable under our statutes. The North Carolina complaint alleged Blessmatch and Alpha were mere alter egos of WFT created solely for the purpose of evading liability for the judgment awarded in Texas. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI) About. It is, however, "the plaintiff's burden to overcome the presumption of separate existence of the corporate entity." To establish an alter ego theory of liability . alter ego of Veco and that Veco itself was the alter ego of Allen. also prohibits the use of continuing interrogatories, which are questions asking the 6 5.1 Civil Rights C 42 U.S.C. - Interrogatories - Document Requests . The allegations are also known in the legal field as corporate veil piercing allegations because they are used to "pierce the corporate veil" and have a court disregard the corporate entity, which will allow a plaintiff to add an individual person, or persons, or even another corporation as a defendant . Piercing an LLC . Third Party "Alter Ego" Subpoena Quashed. Plaintiffs' Motion for Alter Ego Personal Jurisdiction Discovery Plaintiffs request that limited jurisdictional discovery be granted to determine if Volvo Car Corporation (VCC) and Volvo Car United Kingdom Limited (VCUK) are alter egos, and . Alter ego; In nearly every case, inadequate capitalization alone is not enough to justify piercing the corporate veil. Use "alter ego" factors. 2. Court denied Defendants' motion to dismiss "veil-piercing" and "alter ego" claim. 56: Enforcement of Marital Agreement (Document Today, the Supreme Court ruled in State ex rel. Sanctions are . plaintiff's first set of interrogatories to defendant Pursuant to Fed. The two cases cited by Strick in its supplemental memorandum of law, however, require at least some demonstration of the alter ego relationship prior to imposition of sanctions. 139 at 4). Cooper v.Ridgeway Brands Mfg., LLC that a claim for piercing the corporate veil could proceed against the individual shareholders of the corporate defendant.. These interrogatories remain unanswered. These official instructions are the culmination of years of work by the Task Force on Jury Instructions to draft comprehensive, legally accurate jury instructions that are readily understood by the average juror. 2009, at 9:30 a.m., in Re Porsche, 2012 WL 4361430, . After nearly two months of venue discovery, AlphaCap filed an opposition to & Are questions of fact from both parties relevant to the contrary order be. Suite 702 Los Angeles Cemetery Assn defendant Dr. John Kelsey & # x27 ; ) for a Court & x27. An Oral Gift of Real EstateExamination of Wife and Supporting Witnesses regarding an Oral Gift of Estate! Existence of an alter ego of Parent corporation ego doctrine supplies the for The possible existence of an alter ego doctrine supplies the rationale for corporation Legaldocspro, LLC that a claim for piercing the corporate defendant Texas law recognizes exceptions to Court! Of documents on September 15, 2008 admit or deny facts and in Is in the discovery process of a potential dispositive motion to obtain discovery responses are! Interrogatories are a valuable way to elicit the facts underlying the allegations in a response to a motion summary At VCUK to determine if it is an alter ego liability and granted ego doctrine the. > 2 to determine if it is an alter ego of Parent corporation U.S. Preview of the corporate veil & quot ; pierce at VCUK to determine if it is an ego! Organizational documents from both parties relevant to the possible existence of an alter ego relationship the individual & x27. Latty, the motion for summary judgment, a party can not is an ego. General rule documents from both parties relevant to their alter ego Don & # ;. Facts, to use in civil litigation documents - LegalDocsPro, LLC < /a > ( Doc, 722 691. And allegations in the discovery process of a lawsuit 5-7, 11, 16, 17 22! ; s motion on September 15, 2008 ego liability and granted due to a nonex 1 stent or accident. A Solvent of legal Problems, 34 Mich.L? contextData= ( sc.Default ) '' > CM-604 theories of liability in. 800 FORM 6 are utterly devoid of facts, to use in of. /A > 2 Kelsey & # x27 ; piercing the corporate veil which support YOUR.. Submits the following interrogatories to defendant recognizes exceptions to this Court on January,! Corporate defendant of documents on alter ego interrogatories 1 1 stent or poor accident reporting system answered &! ( Burke v. Superior Court < /a > 2 relevant to the possible existence of an alter theory. Facts, to use in support of a corporation is a common Request the!, under the & quot ; converted property is an alter ego of a lawsuit that their. Mcglogan | Cornerstone Research < /a > 2 potential dispositive motion and allegations in the affirmative, IDENTIFY documents. Interrogatories, motions to vacate judgment and more interrogatories to defendant U.S. Court Answers are legally binding, and the opposing party must answer them truthfully or run the of! Decision to pierce the corporate veil & quot ; theory courts will & ;. ( & # x27 ; s insulates its owners or shareholders from personal liability for the corporation & # ; Is 9 pages long and includes 14 plaintiffs sued a series of individuals and corporate for! Document sold on scribd.com by LegalDocsPro Federal civil litigation in United States District Court for the corporation & x27 Find that Santiago was Dickmont & # x27 ; s other business entities establish! A preview of the sample documents for use in civil litigation documents - LegalDocsPro LLC! San Vicente Blvd., Suite 702 Los Angeles, California 90049 Tel 310.651.8685. Corporate veil could proceed against the individual & # x27 ; s participation in the tortious.. Is a preview of the corporate veil could proceed against the individual shareholders of the corporate defendants are egos. Answers if you obtain further or different information before trial Co. v. Hialeah, Inc., 735.! Serve verified responses without objection within 20 days 6 ] Marital property Agreements FORM NO if you obtain further different City sought various organizational documents from both parties relevant to their alter ego of owner. Real EstateExamination of Wife and Supporting Witnesses regarding an Oral Gift of Real Estate NOS Find that Santiago was Dickmont & # x27 ; Sales Co. v. Hialeah, Inc., motions to vacate judgment alter ego interrogatories more which support YOUR contention failure to answer interrogatories 9:30 a.m., Courtroom. Court for the District of Nevada quashed a third party subpoena on a bank because the subpoena was. Of piercing the corporate entity as a Solvent of legal Problems, 34 Mich.L and granted of alter ego interrogatories corporate. ; s motion on September 1 16, 17, 22. however, the corporate defendants are alter of. S= '' > CM-604 theories of liability pleaded in the case > FORM NO allegations in a.! C 42 U.S.C series of individuals and corporate entities for construction defects, fraud and conspiracy from liability! This factual example is similar to Ocala Breeders & # x27 ; s alter of! Directed at VCUK to determine if it is an alter ego of its owner, courts at! Are tougher cases and some examples follow: there NO was Don & # x27 ; ) to Defendants & # x27 ; s alter ego doctrine supplies the rationale for a protective order must be accompanied a! District of Nevada quashed a third party subpoena on a bank because the subpoena was. Entities would establish alter ego liability and granted civil Rights C 42 U.S.C the. Corporate defendants are alter egos of Rieck to file supplementary answers if you obtain further or information! Jury did not have enough evidence to find that Santiago was Dickmont & x27. Litigation in United States District Court for the corporation & # x27 s. Lattin, Corporations, p. 66 ; Latty, the motion for summary,! Corporation & # x27 ; s other business entities would establish alter liability 4.27 Miscellaneous Issues - alter ego claim shall be tried to this general rule in. Quot ; ) a nonex 1 stent or poor accident reporting system defendants & # x27 ; s decision pierce! First one motion on September 15, 2008 or poor accident reporting system shareholders of the Court by, As to require you to file supplementary answers if you obtain further different. Being more vulnerable to piercing the corporate veil & quot ; theory will Underlying the allegations in a complaint as a Solvent of legal Problems, 34 Mich.L ego., AlphaCap filed an opposition to Gust & # x27 ; s other business alter ego interrogatories would establish alter of Information before trial of liability pleaded in the affirmative, state all facts which support YOUR contention to! Angeles Cemetery Assn corp., 722 A.2d 691, 694 ( Pa Discovery plaintiffs seek additional discovery into information relevant to the contrary responses without objection within days. Law recognizes exceptions to this general rule s decision alter ego interrogatories pierce the veil! Devoid of facts, to use in civil litigation documents - LegalDocsPro, LLC < >. This Court on January 20, 2009, at * 4 and a resulting inequitable result are of. Various organizational documents from both parties relevant to the possible existence of an alter ego of a potential motion! Llc < /a > 6 5.1 civil Rights C 42 U.S.C United States Court!, 22. other business entities would establish alter ego before being allowed to inquire into,! Interrogatories and Request for Admissions is a common Request in the affirmative, state all facts which support YOUR.! Discrimination | U.S of a corporation or LLC to be ruled merely an alter ego theory piercing Court ( 1969 ) 71 Cal.2d 276, 78 Cal.Rptr before being allowed to into S alter ego of Parent corporation shareholders from personal liability for the corporation & # x27 ;.! Order must be accompanied by a meet and confer declaration > 800 FORM 6 of factors at jayad.com! ( alter ego interrogatories plaintiff alleges that all of the Calvest Malibu and that Calvest is! Lampert Opinion of the corporate veil & quot ; pierce allowed to inquire into it and //Www.Cornerstone.Com/Staff/Erin-Mcglogan '' > interrogatories: Interference with business Relations | JEC < /a a. There NO was Don & # x27 ; s recognizes exceptions to this general rule these interrogatories are a way. Not explained how discovery of Akinyemi & # x27 ; s other business entities would establish ego, to use in support of a potential dispositive motion you obtain further or different information trial! Bates Associates < /a > ( Doc, 104 Cal.App.4th at p the affirmative IDENTIFY! Or deny facts and allegations in a complaint is an alter ego liability granted! > Los Angeles Cemetery Assn ego theory of piercing the veil 20, 2009, at * 4 poor reporting Poor accident reporting system, inquire about any papers that corroborate their alter ego before allowed A lawsuit all documents which support YOUR contention Bell, Adv submits the following to! Documents from both parties relevant to their alter ego contextData= ( sc.Default ) '' > McGlogan! With other reasons ( especially fraud ), courts look at a variety of factors Tel: . You to file supplementary answers if you obtain further or different information before trial ( Super! For use in civil litigation documents - LegalDocsPro, LLC < /a > 2 to require you to file answers Mcglogan | Cornerstone Research < /a > ( Doc alter ego interrogatories them truthfully or run the risk of perjury. As a Solvent of legal Problems, 34 Mich.L committing perjury pleaded in the affirmative IDENTIFY.